Severalnines Blog
The automation and management blog for open source databases

About cloud lock-in and open source databases

Vinay Joosery
Posted in:

The cloud is no longer a question of if, but of when. Many IT leaders, however, find that one consistent barrier to their adoption of the cloud is vendor lock-in. What do you do when you are forced to stay with a provider that no longer meets your needs?

But is cloud lock-in a problem?

While it appears that you are able to move your workload from one cloud to another without being penalised economically, (the utility billing methods of the major pay-as-you-go platforms like Amazon Web Services or Azure ensure that you would only pay for services used, rather than paying for provisioned resources that may or may not be used.), the reality is that it might not work if the exact services and resources that you are using aren’t available on the cloud you’re migrating to.

Hardware is commodity, and if Cloud Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) is just about renting VMs by the hour, then Cloud IaaS has very little lock-in. But cloud lock-in occurs when you adopt services beyond basic IaaS. The major cloud vendors do not support value-added services the same way, and this is especially true for database services. AWS, Google, Microsoft Azure, Oracle and IBM have cloud database services that work differently and are proprietary in nature, in some cases with specific APIs and data models. This means that even an open source database, combined with all the cloud vendor’s behind the hood automation, may not easily be migrated to another service.

Data can be the most important asset to the organisation, and is critical to the success of cloud applications. It is also hard to move as it is stateful, meaning that the application keeps track of the state of the interaction with users and other systems. The more data a user has, the harder it is to move. Services and applications also tend to gravitate towards the data. For this reason, the cloud vendors will go to great lengths to run and manage your data. For instance, it is free, and relatively easy, to move any amount of data into an AWS EC2 instance, but you’ll have to pay to transfer data out of AWS. The database services on Amazon are only available on Amazon, so good luck if you want to migrate to a new cloud provider or use multiple hosting providers for your application. This puts you, as customer, in a weak negotiating position and locks you into your current cloud vendor.

So, AWS has RDS, Aurora and DynamoDB. Microsoft has Azure DocumentDB and Azure SQL Database. Google has Cloud BigTable, Cloud Datastore, and Cloud SQL.

Severalnines recently joined the party with the NinesControl cloud service.

There are plenty of cloud databases out there already, so what makes NinesControl different? Well, if you are not prepared to go “all in” with a single cloud provider, then you might want to have a good look at NinesControl. It allows you to separate your data from the underlying cloud infrastructure. It supports multiple clouds, you can even bring it on-prem. The automation and management builds upon ClusterControl, a proven product used in production by companies like Cisco, Monster, AVG, BT, Eurovision amongst others.

If you want to avoid cloud vendor lock-in, then take control of your data.

Related Post

Let the new ClusterControl secure your MongoDB deployments

Announcing the release of ClusterControl for MongoDB, which completes our vision to let you fully manage MongoDB whether on premise or in the cloud. With a full array of newly expanded features for MongoDB, ClusterControl provides developers and DBAs an alternative system with which to securely deploy and manage their open source database infrastructures.

Video: An Overview of the Features & Functions of ClusterControl

Severalnines Support Engineer Art van Scheppingen demonstrates the top features and functions of ClusterControl by Severalnines.

Watch the evolution of ClusterControl for MySQL & MongoDB

ClusterControl has come a long way since its release in 2012.  Here are some interesting facts and figures on how it’s being used and by whom.

Announcing ClusterControl 1.4 - the MySQL Replication & MongoDB Edition

Release of ClusterControl 1.4 with key new features related to MySQL Replication and MongoDB in particular, along with performance improvements and bug fixes.